Rough Draft: Detroit's Liberal/Progressive Union-entrenched Welfare-state Legacy: Half of Detroiters are Functionally Illiterate

by the Left Coast Rebel

This morning I am working on a rough draft of a piece that parallels the decay of California and the city of Detroit. I'm not sure if I will submit it or where it will end up but here's what it's shaping up as, so far:

California and Detroit Highlight the Unintended Consequences of Progressive Government

Victor Davis Hanson writes at Pajamas Media today of the cradle-to-grave welfare state disaster that is now the Once-Golden state of California. In specific, he writes of California's underground economy and massive unemployment in the San Joaquin Valley. Like me, Hanson's roots go back decades here. Year by year, decade by decade, concerned onlookers like us have traced the predictable path that laissez faire progressive policy, unfettered illegal immigration coupled with generous entitlement handouts and one-party Democratic rule has led the state.

The California blight of big-government consequences can be seen in numbers and charts: high and persistent unemployment, lack of upward mobility and opportunity and the wholesale quashing of the entrepreneurial spirit and profit motive and the resulting lost vision of a unique 19th Century, Gold-Rush inspired version American Dream that so captivated the world -- the California Dream.

Nevertheless, economics alone belie the worst result of progressive government: spiritual atrophy. As socialism, the quiet racism of low expectations and entitlement mentality run amok rots the human soul it also takes with it the dignity and drive for a purpose that centers healthy, fulfilled, individual lives.

Anything but compassionate, food stamps, handouts, subsidies for every need (and want) enslave those that they purport to "help", often creating a cycle of soulless dependency that generations, for the most part, never escape. The ultimate in governmental unintended consequences, socialist welfare state policies actually exacerbate and multiply on a compound basis the precise problems that they aim to alleviate or eliminate. A recent example of this truism came out of Sacramento. Legislators green-lighted a measure that now allows California welfare recipients to purchase once-forbidden items for those on the Golden State dole: cigarettes and alcohol.

Incestuous union/government alliances are the same: turn-of-the-century intentions to protect worker safety and promote fair pay have morphed the Golden State (and national union movement) into a bureaucratic beast that increases unemployment and job scarcity, forces companies overseas, and destroys our domestic and international edge in education. Ever wonder why reform is impossible in education? Lay the blame at the steps of the largest and most powerful union in the United States: the NEA.

For an even more drastic case of government mismanagement than California -- or perhaps California in 10 or 20 years -- one needs to look no further than the city of Detroit. In addition to displaying every progressive policy ever cooked up by collectivist bean counters, Detroit now boasts of another mind-numbing accomplishment.

50% illiteracy among adults

It wasn't always so. Even in recent history, Detroit was one of America's finest examples of national pride and work ethic and the country's ability to outdo the rest of the world in a key sector of the international economy: automobile production.

Now, Detroit is a crime-and-narcotic-ridden, illiterate, sprawling welfare hub that serves as the starkest warning of the end result of where our the federal government is taking the entire nation. The slide happened willingly by government edict, handout and rubber-stamped bureaucratic approval. And as what will willingly be the predictable outcome of the state of the state of California: the people of Detroit -- at least at one point -- had a choice.

The unintended consequences of Detroit's 100-year experiment in progressive policy stands as the starkest example of where our nation should not go, fifty-percent illiteracy is just the icing on the cake of decline.

However, if we continue to ignore history, the laws of economics and of man; is Motor City's disastrous decline the future of America? Will California's incredible decline be the canary in the coalmine for the rest of America? Or will both examples be just a forgotten chapter in the history of socialism?

She -- America -- as well as future generations, deserve so much better.

Any suggestions or directions I could take this? Thoughts, anyone?


  1. LCR this is a fascinating subject to me. To drive your point home, I'd love to see a thorough comparison of Detroit/California to a relevant conservative city or state. Complete with healthy growth, wealth building for everyone, low crime, plenty of personal freedoms, etc. I'm assuming this would be some place in or like Texas, Florida, etc. Places like North Dakota don't count to me because their populations aren't as diverse and are quite small.

  2. what are the premises of Socialism?
    what is the foundational basis of socialism?
    What is the goal of socialism?
    what is the history of socialistic societies?

    Does the individual solely exist for the purpose of serving the collective or does the collective solely exist for the purpose of serving the individual? why?

  3. No offense man, but are you kidding? Detroit is a veritable cornucopia of dismalness and the facts are all right there at your little Googlin' finger tips. This isn’t some complicated social issue, the town just sucks. And the government there is killing their people and their people are too ignorant to know it or do anything about it.

    Middle class white flight of the 60's, middle class black flight of the past ten years, political corruption on a Chicago level, a busted industry, over taxation, over taxation that can't even meet the needs of Detroit’s bloated local government, racial strife, etc.

  4. Mike: I think you're missing the larger picture w/Detroit in that many of the same progressive policies that are destroying California have been taking placer there for decades...

    It's an extreme example of the end result of welfare-statism.

  5. With current trend, I expect California to parallel Detroit, albeit at a lesser level. I would not be surprised to see California decline about one third as much as Detroit. I don't think we will see such an exodus of population or jobs, but we will see continued loss of jobs, economic growth and the population of poor will increase , so too will the welfare entitlements...the next decade will, IMO, make or break California as a global economic power and engine of growth and entrepreneurialism.

  6. There are areas in the central valley and inland empire that have half built tracts of homes that were abandoned mid construction, these will look like an inner city Detroit neighborhood in a few short years should the project not be completed.


Commenting here is a privilege, not a right. Comments that contain cursing or insults and those failing to add to the discussion will be summarily deleted.