New Poll Supposedly Shows Americans Unwilling to Make Tough Choices Concerning Entitlements

by the Left Coast Rebel

This WSJ/NBC poll, taken at face value, is discouraging:

Less than a quarter of Americans support trimming Social Security or Medicare to tackle the country's budget deficit, according to a new Wall Street Journal/NBC News poll that illustrates the challenge facing lawmakers seeking voter support for altering entitlement programs.

The poll, conducted between Feb. 24 and 28, found strong opposition for cuts to these entitlement programs across all age groups and ideologies. Even tea party supporters, by a nearly 2-to-1 margin, declared cuts to Social Security "unacceptable."

The poll, however, revealed willingness by some respondents to make sacrifices to keep the programs from going broke.

Well over half of Americans favor bumping the retirement age to 69 by 2075, up from 66 now. An even larger share supports reducing retirement and Medicare payments to wealthier Americans.
The opposition against entitlement cuts comes four months after voters elected a crop of governors and conservative federal lawmakers who campaigned against government spending. Congressional Republicans have focused so far on cuts to discretionary spending. But a small group of U.S. senators in both parties has begun talks over changes to entitlement programs, as well as to the tax code.

House Republicans want to make entitlement reductions a key part of their next budget, while several likely 2012 GOP candidates vow to propose ways to shore up the finances of Social Security and Medicare as part of any campaign.

But Republican Bill McInturff and Democrat Peter Hart, the pollsters who conducted the survey, said it raised warning signs for anyone proposing cuts to those programs, which provide retirement benefits to seniors and help pay for their health-care, and to Medicaid, a health plan for the poor. The costs of those programs, which already make up 43% of federal spending, are expected to balloon in coming years.

Cutting government is going to be hard, there's no way around that. We need to educate our friends, families and neighbors on what to expect from government and where this nation is heading (and where it already is) if we let the status quo continue. My friend Donald Douglas puts it well:

It's a classic problem of the modern welfare state. As government grows to accommodate increasing demands for economic security, the political system gets locked into a collective action problem that disables the systems capacity to respond to economic crises. The going would be a tad bit easier if the voters dump the Democrats in 2012, which will be tough but not impossible, especially of economic growth remains tepid.
I'm eternally optimistic: I think Americans will stand by doing the right thing when confronted with the alternative (bankruptcy).

Via Memeorandum.


  1. You hit the nail on the head with "taken at face value." I'd really like to see how the survey questions were actually worded. Especially given that more than half the respondents still supported raising the retirement age to 69.

  2. LCR you are spot on. Nobody wants cuts in their backyard. We all have a stake in Social Security and if we don't change it none of us now or our children can expect squat out of these programs. This includes Social Security, Medicare, and elimination of certain departments to altogether ie Dept of education.

  3. The only "entitlement" I want is for the Govt to get off my back and let me enjoy my liberties!
    The very fact that "social" security is part of the federal budget is my first concern. Even a clue that Govt programs are destine to failure. It's no more than a Federal Ponzi scheme.

  4. You can't run a nation with ballot measures. Direct democracy doesn't work. Monumental problems can't be boiled down to simple questions that fit on a little card. So why do we see so many of these damnable polls?

    We'll find our way out of the wilderness by recruiting and supporting strong conservative leaders...not by listening to Eeyores like Allahpundit who overinterpret the results of oversimplified poll questions.

  5. Thanks, guys. We shouldn't forget that the realignment with a sensible, limited govt is going to be a tough haul. Tough, but possible!

    RK - Not a fan of Allah, his Eeyore routine and neocon/RINO proclivites are a huge turn off. Also, he was more of a critic of Rand Paul than any big-spending statist GOPer -- that tells me everything about where he stands.


Commenting here is a privilege, not a right. Comments that contain cursing or insults and those failing to add to the discussion will be summarily deleted.